We’ll be closing the ice cream window November 1, but you can enjoy our ice cream year-round!

The Arctic Island Cafe is open seven days a week.

Our Story

We’re family. As new owners of Arctic Island & Cafe (formerly Broadway Cafe and Arctic Island Ice Cream) we look forward to joining with the community to create a welcoming, warm and inviting space. We believe in people: we hire locally, encourage community members to come by, and we partner with local groups. We believe in place: we are a part of the neighborhood and look forward to meeting residents and visitors alike. We believe in product: as much as possible we source locally, our ice cream is made onsite and we offer delicious coffee, sandwiches, salads and pizza to nurture you! Come and stay awhile.


Ice Cream from our own recipes

Coffee from Tug Hill Artisan Roasters

Sandwiches (including fresh-baked gluten free bread)

Salads of all kinds

Pizza, delicious and filling

Baked Goods from Provisions

See Full Menu

Images shot on location at Butler.

“The Broadway Cafe is hidden behind its more popular sibling, Arctic Island. But make no mistake, Broadway [now known as Arctic Island Cafe] serves up some excellent sandwiches. Just leave room for ice cream next door.”

— Syracuse.com


Subscribe to our Mailing List